The Constitution uses the phrase “Indians not taxed” to exclude Native people from apportionment for political representation and taxation. On the one hand, this is an odd choice of language. It implies that some Indians were being taxed, such that taxpaying could meaningfully distinguish Indians within the scope of the polity from those beyond it. But it’s rather difficult to identify Native peoples who did pay taxes in the colonies. Indeed, Native people were more likely to be considered taxable property themselves, as slaves toiling in homes or on plantations. Even more prominently, Native people were a tax burden: wars against Indigenous armies prompted some of the earliest taxes in the colonies.
On the other hand, denoting Native nations as untaxed might have been the best choice of words. Taxation by an outside power had come to define subordination to empire; disclaiming the power to tax “Indians” was, by this logic, an eminently appropriate proxy for Native sovereignty.
This paper attempts to disentangle the puzzle of “Indians not taxed.” It lays out eighteenth century precedents for Native taxpaying and tax immunity in the colonies, with special attention to the interwoven systems of Indian slavery and tribute-taking in Virginia. It asks why the framers chose to refer to taxation instead of other categories, given the array of legal statuses that determined membership in the colonies. The paper finds that the most likely tax framers had in mind were poll taxes, or tithes, which in Virginia discriminated between English, Africans, and Natives. Ultimately, it argues that Native sovereignty was understood as material and economic, not only legal, and took shape in a world that measured political membership by taxing labor power.
"Indians not Tithed? Traces of Colonial Labor Regimes in U.S. Constitutionalism"
Presenter(s)
Paper