This paper on the history of retirement finance will narrate the ways in which the Volcker shock sped up the replacement of defined benefit plans (pensions) with defined contribution (401(k)s). It will interweave the interrelated history of technological developments in financial computing, telecommunications, and market infrastructure that enabled the administration of millions of individual worker accounts’ access to the stock market, shifting risk onto employees.
Manufacturing industries’ pension plans were hard-hit by the deep recession induced by Volcker. Capital intensive and interest-rate sensitive industries struggled as the price of borrowing skyrocketed. Executives moved to cut fixed labor costs – both current employee numbers and their retirement pledges, freezing or abandoning pension plans. Unions struggled to combat these cuts as they lost bargaining power with high unemployment and inability to strike.
But retirement finance became valuable as well as expensive. Volcker’s shock turned existing pensions into targets for asset-stripping by a wave of Wall Street “pension raids.” Executives killed pension plans to protect their companies but sacrificed worker retirement stability. They used the Tax Reform Act of 1986 and Section 401(k) of the Internal Revenue Code to reframe retirement security from a collective-backed employer promise to a matter of individual financial literacy and market participation, backed by an eager personal finance industry.
The influx of retirement investors was enabled by technologies that administered millions of individual worker accounts and gave everyday employees direct access to the stock market, otherwise prohibitively expensive and practically impossible. From direct deposit and automatic 401(k) payroll processing, to the digital automation of electronic trading, to the mainframe recordkeeping, fractional share accounting, and computerized order routing of emerging retail personal investment firms, to the new forms of electronic market data and account information that enabled individual investors to self-manage their retirement, the retirement finance revolution was technologized.
"The Shock and the System: Monetary Policy, Financial Technology, and the Structural Transformation of American Retirement"
Paper
Panel